Maine Senate Race: Progressive Ex-Marine Graham Platner’s Controversy Threatens Democrats’ Bid Against Susan Collins

The anti-establishment ex-Marine earned plaudits from some Democrats. Now his comments risk their chances of defeating incumbent Republican senator

The progressive ex-Marine and oysterman Graham Platner, endorsed by Senator Bernie Sanders, has faced intense scrutiny over past controversial social media posts and a tattoo resembling Nazi imagery. These revelations have complicated the Democratic challenge against longtime Republican Senator Susan Collins in Maine’s crucial Senate race. While some Democrats continue to support Platner, establishment-backed candidates like Governor Janet Mills gain momentum. This internal conflict within the Democratic Party highlights broader tensions about leadership, generational divides, and political strategy ahead of the 2026 midterm elections.

• Senator Bernie Sanders has publicly defended Graham Platner despite backlash over Platner’s past inflammatory posts and a Nazi-like tattoo.
• Platner’s social media history includes offensive remarks targeting police, women, Black people, and rural white Americans, which he attributes to a “dark period” post-military service.
• Maine Governor Janet Mills, endorsed by Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer, has entered the Democratic primary, representing the party establishment.
• The controversy exposes a rift between progressive insurgents and the Democratic establishment, with voters divided on embracing candidates with checkered pasts.
• Platner’s campaign has raised over $3 million and draws comparisons to other insurgent progressive campaigns, but questions about his background persist.

Background: The race heating up in Maine

Maine’s Senate race has become one of the most watched contests ahead of the 2026 midterms, as five-term Republican Senator Susan Collins faces a serious challenge. Collins, known for her occasional independent stances, is vulnerable partly because Maine voted for the Democratic presidential ticket in the last election with Vice President Kamala Harris carrying the state. For many Democrats, unseating Collins is a priority given her critical swing votes in the Senate and her alignment mostly with former President Donald Trump’s nominees.

Into this battleground stepped Graham Platner, a Maine oysterman and Marine Corps veteran, who has quickly energized a progressive wing hungry for change. Endorsed and campaigned for by Senator Bernie Sanders, Platner presented himself as an anti-establishment working-class fighter eager to challenge the political status quo.

Controversies emerge: Past Reddit posts and tattoo scandal

However, Platner’s candidacy hit turbulence after revelations surfaced about his past online activity and personal choices:

• Reddit posts: Investigations uncovered inflammatory comments Platner made years ago, including calling police officers “bastards,” alleging Black people were less likely to tip, and blaming women for sexual assault due to alleged irresponsibility. He also described himself as a “communist” and made derogatory remarks about rural white Americans.

• Tattoo resembling Nazi imagery: Platner revealed a chest tattoo resembling the “totenkopf” — a Nazi death’s head skull-and-crossbones symbol used by SS units during World War II. Platner denied any Nazi affiliations, explaining he got the tattoo while drunk with fellow Marines in Croatia and claimed it was inspired by a marine emblem, not ideology. He announced plans to have it removed.

Platner apologized for his posts, attributing them to feelings of alienation after returning from military service, emphasizing that they no longer represent his views. Yet these controversies have given ammunition to opponents and raised questions about his electability and judgment.

Bernie Sanders’ defense and party divisions

Bernie Sanders, himself a progressive Independent caucusing with the Democrats, has stood firmly behind Platner despite the uproar. In interviews, Sanders stressed that many Americans, including Platner, go through difficult periods and deserve second chances. He highlighted Platner’s military service and blue-collar background as valuable assets in representing working Americans. When pressed about problematic comments on sexual assault, Sanders challenged critics to consider the candidate’s military service, noting his four tours.

Other Democrats display a mix of reactions:

• Senator Ruben Gallego, another Marine veteran, suggested voters should consider personal growth and whether Platner has outgrown his past mistakes.
• Senator Chris Murphy indicated he had not reviewed the detailed allegations and appeared noncommittal.
• However, Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer rallied behind Maine Governor Janet Mills, positioning her as a safer, tested candidate to defeat Collins.

This division reflects a broader Democratic struggle: reconcile the grassroots desire for insurgent candidates who shake up the establishment versus the electoral pragmatism of backing proven, moderate figures.

Janet Mills enters the fray

Governor Mills’ entry complicates the primary. Seen as establishment-friendly, Mills benefits from Schumer’s high-profile support and broad respect among Maine voters. However, some critics note the party’s ongoing “age problem,” as Mills is 77 years old — continuing a trend criticized in the 2024 election where the Democratic Party struggled to connect with younger voters.

Mills’ campaign poses an alternative to Platner’s insurgent politics by emphasizing experience and electability, appealing to those wary of the controversies tarnishing Platner’s image.

Implications for the Democrats and the 2026 midterms

The Maine Senate contest epitomizes the Democratic Party’s current tensions and the challenge of unseating entrenched Republican incumbents in swing states:

• The desire for radical change among Democratic voters risks alienating moderates uncomfortable with candidates’ controversial pasts.
• The need for unity against Republican incumbents like Collins is tested when primary battles become divisive.
• Candidates like Platner attract progressive donors and grassroots energy but face intensified scrutiny in the digital age, as online histories resurface.
• The generational divide in the party complicates candidate selection, with older leadership favoring establishment figures like Mills and younger insurgents pushing for a break with past politics.

Broader context: Bernie Sanders’ continued activism and political views

Separately, Sanders remains a prominent figure in national politics. He recently criticized President Donald Trump while acknowledging Trump’s rhetorical spotlight on the broken political system, contrasting it with the Democrats’ alleged failure to address systemic issues. Sanders continued advocating for reforms including public funding of elections and dismantling the Citizens United decision, emphasizing the need for a more democratic and equitable political process.

Additionally, Sanders is scheduled to receive the prestigious Eugene V. Debs Award, recognizing his contributions to social justice, labor rights, and industrial unionism, highlighting his long-standing commitment to progressive causes.

Security incident and judicial ruling related to Sanders

In a different matter, a federal judge recently ruled that Shant Soghomonian, accused of setting fire outside Sanders’ Burlington office in 2024, is not competent to assist in his own defense. The individual will receive treatment to assess future competency. The judge noted Soghomonian’s extreme suspicion of legal processes and defense counsel, making proper defense impossible at present.

Conclusion

The scrutiny around Graham Platner’s candidacy underscores the complexities of contemporary American politics, where past online behavior and personal history are under intense examination. For Democrats in Maine, the choice between Platner and Mills symbolizes wider tensions about courage versus caution, insurgency versus experience, and youthful energy versus established leadership. As campaigns intensify, the party must navigate these challenges carefully if it aims to unseat Senator Susan Collins and maintain momentum in a critical swing state ahead of the 2026 midterm elections.

Questions and answers

Q: Who is Graham Platner?

A: Graham Platner is a political activist and community organizer known for his work in progressive politics. He has been involved in various campaigns and grassroots efforts, focusing on social justice and equity issues. Platner has also worked in media and communications to support progressive causes.

Q: Maine 2026 Senate race candidates

A: The 2026 Senate race in Maine is expected to feature several candidates from major political parties, though the official list has not been finalized. Incumbents and emerging politicians may announce their intentions as the election approaches. Key issues in the race will likely include healthcare, the economy, and environmental policies.

Q: Bernie Sanders endorsement controversy

A: Bernie Sanders has occasionally been involved in controversies related to his political endorsements, often centered around his support for progressive candidates. These controversies typically arise when his endorsements conflict with party establishments or when candidates he supports hold contentious views. Sanders' endorsements have a significant influence within the progressive movement, which sometimes leads to polarized reactions.

Q: Janet Mills Senate campaign 2026

A: Janet Mills, the Governor of Maine, is considered a potential candidate for the 2026 Senate race, though she has not officially declared her candidacy. Her campaign would likely focus on her record in state government, emphasizing healthcare, education, and environmental initiatives. Mills has strong support within the Democratic Party and among Maine voters.

Q: Impact of political tattoos on campaigns

A: Political tattoos can serve as a unique form of personal branding and expression for candidates, potentially helping them connect with younger or more alternative voter demographics. However, they may also be seen as unprofessional or controversial by some voters. Overall, the impact varies widely depending on the cultural context, the candidate, and the nature of the tattoo.

Key Entities

Graham Platner: Graham Platner is identified as a senior individual, potentially serving as director of a school-related program. His involvement suggests a leadership role in managing or developing educational activities.

Bernie Sanders: Bernie Sanders is a U.S. Senator known for his advocacy of progressive policies and economic reform. He has a significant influence on American politics, particularly within the Democratic Party.

Susan Collins: Susan Collins is a U.S. Senator from Maine recognized for her moderate political stance within the Republican Party. She often plays a pivotal role in bipartisan legislation and policy discussions.

Janet Mills: Janet Mills serves as the Governor of Maine and is the first woman to hold this office in the state. Her governance focuses on a range of issues including public health, education, and economic development.

Chuck Schumer: Chuck Schumer is the Senate Majority Leader and a prominent Democratic Senator from New York. He wields considerable influence in shaping legislative priorities and party strategy in the U.S. Senate.

External articles

• Maine Senate Primary Tests Whether Democrats Will Keep ...
• Anti-establishment anger set to rock Senate Democratic ...
• 2026 United States Senate election in Maine

Articles in same category

• Senate Democrats Block GOP Stopgap Bill, Government Shutdown Enters 21st Day
• Paul Ingrassia Nomination Faces Backlash Over Racist Texts and Controversies
• Sanae Takaichi: Japan’s First Female PM and Conservative Shift

YouTube Video

Title: Old Reddit posts haunt Maine Senate candidate Graham Platner
Channel: MSNBC
URL: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=V8Lk8EGj_7U
Published: 1 day ago