Josh Naylor and Ernie Clement's Controversial ALCS Game 7 Clash Highlights Toronto's World Series Bid

Game 7 of the American League Championship Series delivered plenty of drama, highlighted by a controversial interference play between former Cleveland teammates Josh Naylor and Ernie Clement

The decisive game seven of the American League Championship Series (ALCS) between the Toronto Blue Jays and Seattle Mariners was packed with intense moments, none more talked about than the controversial interference play involving ex-Cleveland Guardians teammates Josh Naylor and Ernie Clement. Their complex relationship, marked by both collaboration and confrontation, added an extra layer of intrigue to the series. This pivotal moment, coupled with dramatic performances like George Springer’s clutch home run, shaped a thrilling series that ended with Toronto advancing to their first World Series in 32 years.

Key points:

• Josh Naylor was ruled to have intentionally interfered with Ernie Clement’s throw to first base, resulting in a rare interference double play early in Game 7, stirring controversy and debate.
• Naylor and Clement’s rivalry stems from a serious collision in 2021 when both played for Cleveland, leaving Naylor sidelined with a fractured ankle and fueling competitive encounters since.
• Naylor’s aggressive baserunning style, described as “running the bases like a madman,” was on full display during the series, including a notably forceful slide into third base involving Clement.
• Blue Jays pitcher Shane Bieber, another former Guardian, visibly showed frustration over the interference play, reflecting the heightened emotions of the series.
• The Blue Jays’ lineup contributed depth and consistent production throughout the postseason, highlighted by George Springer’s game-winning home run in Game 7, securing Toronto’s spot in the World Series.
• Discussion around offseason moves points to Josh Naylor as a sought-after free agent, with possibilities of returning to Seattle, signing with New York teams, or other contenders, though a Cleveland reunion seems unlikely.

---

Intense confrontation between former teammates in ALCS Game 7

Game 7 of the ALCS between Toronto and Seattle proved a defining moment not only in the series but for former Cleveland Guardians teammates Josh Naylor and Ernie Clement. Early in the first inning, a ground ball from Jorge Polanco led to a remarkable and controversial interference call. Clement fielded a ball near second base and attempted to throw to first for a double play, but Naylor, standing on first base, appeared to intentionally place himself in the path of the throw. Replays clearly showed Naylor jumping up into the ball's trajectory, an action described as deliberate by commentators and the umpires, who quickly ruled interference and called a double play.

The incident enraged Blue Jays pitcher Shane Bieber as he walked off the mound, angrily confronting Naylor. Paul Hoynes commented during the Cleveland Baseball Talk podcast that while Naylor deserves credit for gamesmanship, the stunt was too blatant to be accepted without consequence.

This play was not an isolated incident in the series; prior episodes saw Naylor execute his aggressive baserunning with a hard slide into third base that forced a physical collision with Clement. This style has long been part of Naylor’s approach, earning him a reputation for playing bases aggressively.

A rivalry born from collision and intensity

Underlying the on-field confrontations is a deeper history between Naylor and Clement, dating back to 2021 when both were with Cleveland. At Target Field, an intense and frightening collision occurred as Naylor, playing right field, and Clement, at second base, converged for a play, resulting in Naylor fracturing his right ankle and missing the remainder of that season. Since then, their paths have crossed regularly, often in contentious ways.

Paul Hoynes underscored the physicality involved, noting the mental challenge Clement faces when Naylor barges toward him on the basepaths, particularly recalling that injurious collision. Joe Noga reflected on the difficulty and danger of fielding throws with aggressive runners like Naylor involved, emphasizing the added tension that comes with their shared history and rivalry.

This backstory transforms their encounters from routine plays to emotionally charged moments filled with subtext that fans and commentators find compelling.

The bigger picture: Toronto advances and the World Series awaits

Alongside the drama of Naylor and Clement’s interactions, the series showcased other memorable moments. One of the most consequential was George Springer’s late-game three-run home run in Game 7, which secured the Blue Jays’ victory and advanced them to their first World Series appearance since 1992.

Springer’s performance capped a game that included perfect execution of situational plays like a crucial bunt by Andres Jimenez, evoking memories of his Cleveland tenure. Commentators praised the Blue Jays for getting contributions consistently throughout their lineup, emphasizing their depth from top to bottom.

The World Series matchup will pit Toronto against the Los Angeles Dodgers, a clash described as “Southern California versus the Great White North.” Analysts see the Dodgers as favorites due to their star-studded lineup and pitching staff, but Toronto’s balanced offense and reliable bullpen are expected to provide stiff competition.

The forthcoming World Series promises significant strategic decisions around pitching rotations, with speculation about how Dodgers star Shohei Ohtani might be deployed alongside other starters.

Offseason prospects: Josh Naylor’s uncertain future

With the postseason concluded for Seattle, attention now turns to offseason movements. Josh Naylor, who played strongly throughout the playoffs, is among the more attractive free agents on the market. Analysts estimate he could command $18–20 million annually, potentially over a multi-year contract.

While Seattle holds exclusive negotiating rights for a limited window, other teams such as the New York Yankees and Mets could enter the bidding. Chicago White Sox interest has been speculated but seems unlikely due to past on-field rivalries.

Naylor’s potential return to Cleveland appears improbable due to the Guardians’ direction and previous trade decisions. Similarly, a return to Toronto is unlikely given Vlad Guerrero’s long-term contract at first base and roster configuration.

Regardless, Naylor’s postseason performance raised his profile substantially, and multiple clubs are expected to express serious interest in securing him during free agency.

---

Conclusion

Game 7 of the ALCS was more than a contest for a World Series berth—it was a narrative filled with personal rivalries, dramatic plays, and poignant moments involving former Cleveland Guardians players. The controversial interference by Josh Naylor against Ernie Clement highlighted not only the competitiveness at play but the entwined careers of two players whose shared history adds depth to their rivalry. As the Toronto Blue Jays move forward to face the Los Angeles Dodgers, fans can anticipate a thrilling World Series. Meanwhile, the offseason landscape awaits decisions about key free agents like Naylor, whose next destination remains a topic of significant interest in the baseball world.

Questions and answers

Q: Josh Naylor interference ALCS Game 7

A: In ALCS Game 7, Josh Naylor was involved in a controversial interference play that became a pivotal moment in the game. The incident involved Naylor making contact with a fielder while attempting to reach a base, leading to a debate over whether it was intentional interference. This play sparked significant discussion among fans and analysts, as it potentially impacted the outcome of the closely contested game.

Q: Ernie Clement and Josh Naylor rivalry

A: Ernie Clement and Josh Naylor have developed a competitive dynamic on the field, though it is not widely characterized as a heated rivalry. Both players have faced each other multiple times in MLB matchups, often contributing key plays for their respective teams. Their interactions tend to be more about professional competition rather than personal animosity.

Q: Toronto Blue Jays advances to World Series

A: The Toronto Blue Jays secured their spot in the World Series by winning the American League Championship Series (ALCS). This marked a significant achievement for the franchise, showcasing strong performances from their roster and management. Their advancement energized their fan base and set the stage for a highly anticipated championship series against the National League champion.

Q: Josh Naylor free agency prospects

A: Josh Naylor's performance with his current team has made him a notable player in the upcoming free agency period. Teams seeking a versatile left-handed hitter with power and the ability to play multiple positions may express interest in signing him. His market value will be influenced by his recent statistics, health, and overall contribution to his team's success.

Q: ALCS Game 7 controversial plays

A: ALCS Game 7 was marked by several controversial plays that had fans and analysts debating the fairness and impact on the game's outcome. These included questionable calls on interference, close plays at the bases, and disputed umpire decisions. Such moments added to the intense drama of the game, highlighting the high stakes and pressure faced by players and officials alike.

Key Entities

Josh Naylor: Josh Naylor is a professional baseball player who has played as an outfielder and first baseman for the Toronto Blue Jays. He is known for his power-hitting ability and versatility on the field.

Ernie Clement: Ernie Clement is a Major League Baseball infielder who plays for the Seattle Mariners. He is recognized for his defensive skills and speed on the basepaths.

Toronto Blue Jays: The Toronto Blue Jays are a Major League Baseball team based in Toronto, Canada. They compete in the American League East and have won two World Series championships.

Seattle Mariners: The Seattle Mariners are a Major League Baseball team based in Seattle, Washington, competing in the American League West division. They are known for their passionate fan base and have produced several notable players.

George Springer: George Springer is a Major League Baseball outfielder who has played for teams including the Toronto Blue Jays and Seattle Mariners. He earned recognition for his postseason performances and power-hitting capabilities.

External articles

• Josh Naylor called for interference on bizarre double play ...
• Josh Naylor hit by throw, called for interference double play
• Josh Naylor leaps into throw for bizarre ALCS double play

Articles in same category

• 2024 League Championship Series Highlights: Blue Jays’ Springer Powers ALCS, Dodgers’ Pitching Dominates NLCS
• Toronto Blue Jays Advance to World Series After Thrilling ALCS Game 7 Win
• Don Mattingly's Journey to the 2023 World Series as Blue Jays Bench Coach

YouTube Video

Title: Josh Naylor NAILED 💥game 7
URL: https://www.youtube.com/shorts/g1CW1eBIGzc